The value depends on the question.

Discuss an Appraisal →

START WITH THE INTENDED USE

“What is it worth?” is usually not the first question.

Before an artwork can be valued responsibly, the purpose of the appraisal has to be established.

A work being appraised for insurance may require a different definition of value, market analysis, and effective date from the same work being considered for an estate, charitable contribution, division of property, or damage claim.

That is not a contradiction. It is the nature of appraisal.

The assignment determines the question being asked of the market. The appraiser’s responsibility is to develop an opinion appropriate to that question and supported by relevant evidence.

WHAT IS THE APPRAISAL FOR?

Insurance

Replacement is not simply purchase price plus inflation.

A work may have been acquired years ago, privately, at auction, directly from an artist, or under circumstances that have little relationship to what a comparable replacement would cost today.

Insurance appraisal requires consideration of the particular property, the appropriate definition of value, the relevant market, current evidence, condition, documentation, and the circumstances under which replacement would realistically occur.

Appraisal services may support:

• Insurance scheduling
• Policy and collection reviews
• Updated valuations
• Newly acquired works
• Significant changes in an artist’s market
• Collection documentation

Discuss an Insurance Appraisal →

Estates & Probate

An estate can only make sound decisions about what it understands.

Artwork often enters an estate accompanied by incomplete records, outdated values, family recollections, or assumptions that have never been examined.

A collection may include important works that heirs do not recognize as significant. Other objects may have strong personal meaning but limited market demand. Invoices may be missing. Attribution or provenance information may require additional research.

An independent appraisal provides a documented valuation appropriate to the estate assignment and helps establish a clearer basis for administration and subsequent decisions.

Discuss an Estate Appraisal →

Estate Tax

Estate-tax assignments require a clearly defined effective date, appropriate market research, identification of the property being valued, and analysis consistent with the specific purpose of the appraisal.

The valuation should reflect the evidence relevant to the assignment rather than a current asking price, insurance value, or unrelated auction estimate.

Charitable Contributions

A donation begins with more than generosity.

Artwork considered for a charitable contribution may require a fair market value appraisal prepared for the specific assignment.

Before valuation begins, the property, intended use, effective date, available documentation, attribution, condition, provenance, and applicable reporting requirements should be understood.

Where specialist opinions or additional evidence are necessary, those needs should be identified rather than assumed away.

Discuss a Charitable-Contribution Appraisal →

Damage & Loss

Damage changes more than condition.

When an artwork is damaged, lost, destroyed, or altered, the valuation question may involve more than its value immediately before the event.

Depending on the assignment, the analysis may involve:

• Pre-loss value
• Post-loss value
• Total-loss considerations
• Restoration or treatment
• Diminution in value
• Comparable replacement evidence
• Documentation of prior condition
• Market response to repaired or altered property

A restored work is not automatically worth what it was worth before damage. Nor does every repair materially affect market value.

The particular object, the nature of the damage, the treatment performed, its significance within the artist’s market, and the available evidence all matter.

Discuss a Damage or Loss Matter →

Division of Property

Artwork may form part of a divorce, equitable distribution, inheritance, partnership dissolution, or another division of assets.

An independent appraisal can provide a defined valuation basis for the works involved without advocating for either side of the underlying dispute.

The purpose is to determine what the evidence supports.

Collection Valuation

A collection may require valuation for insurance, planning, documentation, estate purposes, organizational needs, or another defined use.

The assignment may involve a single significant work or hundreds of objects.

Scale changes the logistics. It does not change the fundamental principle:

The purpose of the appraisal comes first.

WHAT AN APPRAISER ACTUALLY EXAMINES

The artist’s name is only the beginning.

Two works by the same artist can have dramatically different markets.

Attribution

Is the work securely identified as being by the artist? Is it attributed to the artist, from the studio, circle, school, or another relationship?

A small change in attribution can create a substantial change in value.

Period

Was the work made during a period of the artist’s career that collectors, institutions, and the market regard differently from other periods?

Medium

A painting, drawing, print, photograph, sculpture, and digital work by the same artist may participate in distinct markets.

Subject

Certain subjects, series, images, or bodies of work may attract substantially different demand.

Condition

Damage, previous repairs, fading, alteration, restoration, or other condition issues may influence how buyers respond to the work.

Condition should be evaluated in relation to the particular object—not reduced to “good” or “bad.”

Provenance

Ownership history can clarify an object’s history, strengthen confidence, create questions, or occasionally affect market interest.

A compelling story is useful only to the extent that the surviving evidence supports it.

Exhibition & Publication History

Museum exhibitions, scholarly publications, catalogue raisonné entries, and other records may contribute important context.

Comparable Market Evidence

A high auction result for another work by the artist is not automatically a useful comparable.

The question is whether the works are actually comparable in period, medium, scale, subject, condition, provenance, quality, and market circumstances.

The Market Itself

Private sales, galleries, regional auctions, international auction houses, dealer transactions, and other market venues do not necessarily provide interchangeable evidence.

The relevant market has to be identified rather than assumed.

THE APPRAISAL PROCESS

Evidence before conclusions.

01 · Define the assignment

Establish the intended use, intended users, effective date, property to be appraised, relevant definition of value, scope, and any known limitations.

02 · Review the property

Determine the appropriate examination requirements and review the works, photographs, measurements, identifying information, condition, and other relevant physical characteristics.

03 · Examine the documentation

Review available invoices, prior appraisals, provenance records, exhibition history, publications, condition reports, certificates, correspondence, and other records relevant to the property.

Documentation is evidence to be evaluated—not accepted simply because it exists.

04 · Identify unresolved questions

Determine whether attribution, authenticity, condition, provenance, title, ownership, or another issue requires additional evidence or specialist expertise.

An appraisal is not automatically an authentication or conservation examination.

Where another specialist is required, the appropriate response is to identify that need rather than guess.

05 · Research the market

Identify and analyze relevant comparable transactions and other market evidence in relation to the particular work and purpose of the assignment.

06 · Develop the opinion

Reconcile the available evidence and develop the valuation conclusion appropriate to the assignment.

07 · Report the analysis

Prepare a written appraisal explaining the property, assignment, methodology, relevant research, assumptions, limiting conditions, and resulting opinion of value.

EXPERIENCE CHANGES WHAT YOU NOTICE

Expertise is often knowing when to slow down.

A date that does not fit.

A label that raises another question.

An attribution that is less certain than the owner believed.

A prior appraisal prepared for an entirely different purpose.

A six-figure auction result that turns out to have almost nothing to do with the work being valued.

After years of working with art, collections, galleries, market records, and the documentation surrounding them, patterns become visible.

The value of experience is not the ability to glance at an object and announce a number.

It is knowing which details deserve another look before the number is reached.

GETTING STARTED

Start with what you have.

You do not need a perfectly organized collection file before making contact.

For an initial discussion, the most useful information usually includes:

• The reason the appraisal is needed
• Any relevant deadline
• The number and general type of objects involved
• Photographs, if available
• Artist, title, medium, and dimensions, if known
• Available invoices or purchase records
• Prior appraisals
• Provenance or ownership documentation
• Condition or conservation records
• The location of the property

Once the assignment is understood, we can identify what additional information or examination may be required.

COMMON QUESTIONS

Can an appraisal tell me whether my artwork is authentic?

Not necessarily.

An appraisal requires an adequate basis for identifying the property being valued, but authentication may require a recognized specialist, artist foundation, catalogue raisonné committee, scientific testing, provenance research, or other evidence outside the appraisal assignment.

If attribution or authenticity is unresolved, that should be identified rather than concealed by the valuation process.

Can an appraisal be completed from photographs?

Sometimes. Sometimes not.

The examination requirements depend on the particular property, purpose of the assignment, available documentation, relevant evidence, and agreed scope.

That determination should be made before the assignment proceeds.

Why can the same artwork have different appraised values?

Because value is defined in relation to purpose, market, effective date, and other assignment conditions.

Insurance replacement value and fair market value answer different questions.

Different answers do not necessarily mean one of them is wrong.

Is an auction estimate an appraisal?

No.

An auction estimate is generally an indication of the range in which an auction house expects bidding may occur.

An appraisal develops an opinion of value for a defined purpose, effective date, and set of assignment conditions.

How often should a collection be reappraised?

There is no universal timetable.

A new appraisal may become appropriate when markets change materially, significant works are acquired, insurance requirements change, a major life or estate event occurs, or an existing valuation no longer reflects the purpose for which it is being used.

How are fees determined?

Fees depend on the nature and scope of the assignment, number and type of objects, documentation available, research requirements, property access, reporting needs, and timing.

The scope and professional fee are established before the engagement begins.

FOR ATTORNEYS, FIDUCIARIES & OTHER PROFESSIONAL ADVISORS

The artwork may be one part of your matter. It is our part to understand.

A client’s estate, insurance matter, charitable gift, divorce, trust, or collection issue can raise valuation questions that sit outside the advisor’s principal field.

Ron Shipmon LLC works with professional advisors to define the art-related assignment, identify the evidence required, and provide independent appraisal analysis appropriate to the matter.

The objective is not to complicate the client’s larger engagement.

It is to make the art question clearer.

Discuss a Client Matter →

CONTACT

Begin with the purpose.

If you require an appraisal of fine art or other significant personal property, contact Ron Shipmon LLC with the reason for the valuation and the general nature of the property involved.

From there, we can determine the appropriate next step.

Discuss an Appraisal →